Big Toe Joint Replacement: What You Need to Know

Big toe joint replacement is a relatively common procedure for people experiencing severe pain or limited mobility due to arthritis, injury, or other conditions. The goal of this surgery is to relieve pain and restore function in the big toe, allowing patients to return to activities they love. As interest in this procedure grows, so do questions about how it works, what to expect, and the potential benefits and risks. Here, we’ll share some common questions people have about big toe joint replacement, including the different types of foot surgery available, the lifespan of a replacement, and specific considerations around the Cartiva toe implant, a popular yet controversial option based on our laypersons’ understanding from investigating these cases.

What Is Big Toe Joint Replacement?

Big toe joint replacement, also known as metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joint replacement, involves removing a damaged joint and replacing it with an artificial one. The procedure seeks to improve the function and alignment of the big toe while reducing pain caused by arthritis, deformities, or traumatic injuries. Doctors typically recommend this surgery when conservative treatments, like physical therapy or medication, no longer provide relief.

There are different types of big toe joint replacement options. Traditional joint replacements use metal or plastic components to replace the joint. More recently, synthetic implants like Cartiva have entered the market, offering a unique approach aimed at maintaining a more natural range of motion.

How Long Does a Big Toe Joint Replacement Last?

The lifespan of a big toe joint replacement depends on several factors, including the type of implant used and the patient’s activity level. Most traditional big toe implants should last between 10 and 15 years. However, synthetic implants, such as the Cartiva implant, claim to offer durability and flexibility for a longer period. We know Cartiva implants have not consistent lasted that long.

Types of Foot Surgery for Big Toe Joint Pain

There are several types of surgeries available to address big toe joint pain, each with its own benefits and limitations. Here’s an overview of the most common options:

Big Toe Joint Replacement: This procedure involves replacing the damaged joint with an artificial implant to restore movement and relieve pain. As mentioned, implants can be metal, plastic, or synthetic materials like Cartiva.
Joint Fusion: Joint fusion, or arthrodesis, permanently fuses the big toe joint, eliminating pain by preventing motion in the damaged joint. While fusion is highly effective for pain relief, it restricts movement.
Cheilectomy: This less invasive surgery removes bone spurs or damaged cartilage from the joint to relieve pain.
Osteotomy: Osteotomy involves cutting and realigning bones to relieve pressure on the joint, potentially slowing the progression of arthritis. Doctors may combine this procedure with other treatments to improve results.

Choosing the right type of foot surgery depends on the extent of joint damage, the patient’s age, lifestyle, and their desire to retain motion in the toe. Surgeons evaluate each case individually to recommend the best approach.

Understanding Cartiva Big Toe Joint Replacement

The Cartiva toe implant has gained attention as a newer option for big toe joint replacement. Unlike traditional metal or plastic implants, Cartiva is made from an alleged biocompatible synthetic material that resembles natural cartilage. The goal of the Cartiva implant is to reduce pain while preserving motion in the joint, making it an attractive option for people who wanted a more natural feel in their big toe after surgery.

Cartiva’s design purports to provide greater flexibility. It is supposed to enable patients to retain more movement compared to traditional implants or joint fusion. However, Cartiva has faced some backlash.

Despite its promises, studies and patient experiences raise concerns about the long-term effectiveness of Cartiva toe implants. Some patients report persistent pain, reduced mobility, and the need for revision surgery following Cartiva toe implants.

Cartiva and the Controversy Around Big Toe Joint Replacements

It appears the company marketed the Cartiva implants as an innovative solution for big toe arthritis. We now have backlash from both patients and medical professionals. The primary concerns center around inconsistent outcomes and the potential need for additional surgeries.

Some patients lack improvement in pain or joint function after Cartiva implantation. Others report adverse reactions or implant failure. In such cases, a secondary procedure may be necessary to replace or remove the implant. This increases costs, extends recovery time, and adds suffering for the patient.

Several studies have shown mixed results regarding Cartiva’s effectiveness. Although the company designed the Cartiva toe implant to mimic the feel and flexibility of cartilage, some patients find that the material does not provide the level of pain relief or durability they expected from the company’s representations.

The Consequences of a Cartiva Toe Implant Failure

The Cartiva toe implant fails according to doctors and patients with whom we work. When it does, it causes pain and other complications. That necessitates additional medical care.

For patients who experience complications, surgery to remove the Cartiva toe implant or a revision surgery may be necessary to correct the issue. This second surgery can involve removing the existing implant, replacing it with a new one, or even opting for joint fusion if the replacement is no longer viable. Patients should discuss the risks and benefits with their surgeon to make an informed decision.

KBA Attorneys is Investigating Big Toe Joint Replacement Cases

As concerns about the effectiveness of Cartiva and other big toe joint replacements grow, KBA Attorneys is actively investigating cases involving patients who have experienced negative outcomes from their surgeries. KBA Attorneys is dedicated to advocating for individuals who may have been misled by claims of Cartiva’s durability or experienced complications post-surgery. We are committed to helping clients understand their legal rights and pursuing compensation where appropriate. Contact us today.

Through our investigations, KBA Attorneys aims to hold manufacturers accountable for any misleading claims or negligence that may have contributed to adverse outcomes for patients. By representing clients who have faced challenges with big toe joint replacements, we hope to shed light on these cases and work toward greater transparency in the medical device industry.

Is Big Toe Joint Replacement Right for You?

Big toe joint replacement can offer significant relief and improved mobility for people suffering from joint pain. However, as with any surgical procedure, it’s essential to understand the risks, benefits, and long-term implications. Patients should consult with a qualified surgeon to discuss their unique needs, expectations, and concerns, especially if considering newer options like the Cartiva implant. Exploring alternative treatments, understanding potential complications, and asking questions about the expected lifespan of the implant can help patients make informed decisions.

Whether you’re considering traditional big toe joint replacement, Cartiva, or another form of foot surgery, staying informed is the first step toward a successful outcome. With the right approach, you can achieve pain relief, regain mobility, and return to the activities you enjoy.

What to do if the Cartiva Toe Implant Fails

After consulting a healthcare professional, speak with an attorney. By working with an experienced legal team like KBA Attorneys, patients who face complications from big toe joint replacements can seek the support and guidance they need to navigate their options and understand their rights. KBA Attorneys remains committed to investigating these Cartiva Toe Implant cases and advocating for individuals affected by faulty medical devices.